Site Logo
Dating online > Looking for a boyfriend > The woman in black book club discussion questions

The woman in black book club discussion questions

Site Logo

In this second novel, The Storycatcher, we learn the haunted history of Black Mountain and its people I love the idea of a "storycatcher", one who after death will catch our story and make sure it is accurate and complete. These are the kind of little details and folklore that imbue Ann Hite's stories Her personal essays and short stories have been published in numerous national anthologies. The Storycatcher is her second Black Mountain novel.

SEE VIDEO BY TOPIC: Book Review - Woman in Black by Susan Hill

SEE VIDEO BY TOPIC: The Woman in Black by Susan Hill [Book Review]

The Women in Black

Site Logo

This topic is about The Woman in Black. Oct 24, AM. Hello All, I'm still reading the book, but I found these discussion questions and liked the first two didn't read the last ones, just in case they give the ending away!

I'm really liking this ghost story and I hope to finish today! The novel opens with a detailed description of happy family life and builds to a ghastly climax.

How does the author create the continual suspense to bring things to their terrifying conclusion? Do you as a reader trust the narrator more because of this? How does this calmness contribute to the effect of the more chilling and supernatural events later in the book?

The description of the woman in black is a gradual unveiling throughout the novel. How effective is this style of description? How do details, such as the cloak or hints of disease, contribute to our growing impression of her?

The author has chosen a woman as the central ghost figure — how is the concept of gender handled in the novel? The story is set very firmly in Victorian times, with clear descriptions of daily life at that time. How does the historical setting add to the horror?

The Woman in Black is a modern ghost story not only in the strength of its writing, but also in its use of the conventions in this genre of writing. How does the author use these conventions to effect, and how does the novel compare to other ghost stories, not only in books but in film as well? Well, it's good you started the thread with those questions, I guess.

Seems to me like they don't contain too many spoilers, either. Though my post sure will. Not really strictly following the questions, though. First of all it wasn't quite clear to me in which age that story takes place. At first I felt like it was the turn of the century 19thth , but then it felt like it would be at least 10 to 20 years later. Especially when it's casually mentioned how that very secluded house has electricity and all. Even the locked bedroom has a socket in the ceiling if I remember correctly , just no bulb, which I found especially odd since it must've been 30 or 40 years at least since that room was used last.

And probably not modernized afterwards. Also the narrator seems to find motorised cars way too common he expects! At least this is not the case and the only person with a motorised car seems to be that really rich guy.

Also I don't think there are many "clear descriptions of daily life at that time" as question five asks. That's not actually something that bothers me that much, my perception of life at the time may be wrong, too, but when people emphasize on the Victorian setting that much, it feels kind of odd to me. I liked the scary parts.

Unfortunately they were over way too quickly. There could've been more to them. Some more time to raise the suspension level, for example. I think that the narrator tries to explain everything rationally but then he's so extremely scared from what happens, except the author didn't really let me feel like it was that much that actually happened But it was a nice read, nonetheless.

Oct 24, PM. I enjoyed the book in it's brevity. I especially liked the setup of the happily married man having to face his past. I was continually curious about what exactly was going to happen to Stella in order to have Arthur married to some one else years later. Arthur endeared himself to me when he was so clearly effected by the sounds of the pony and trap catastrophe spectres on the marsh, but I began to roll my eyes at him due to his insistence on returning to a haunted house.

I think my favorite part of the story was the setting of Eel Marsh House: the lonely mansion with a ruinous church and graveyard that's only accessible through a commonly flooded causeway. It was interesting to see Arthur start romanticizing the place and finding it beautiful when, as the reader, you find it ominous.

I haven't seen either the mini series or the movie, but I could imagine seeing either of them just to get a distinct visual of the marsh and causeway! The story definitely slowed for me after the discovery of the letters, and it became plain who the Woman in Black was and why she was an unhappy ghost. However, it was never clear why the villagers were so terrified of her until her relationship with children was revealed at the very end, and suddenly my skin began to crawl.

Somehow, the idea of a female haunt hurting children is very creepy to me. I'm glad I read the book, and I enjoyed it especially for the setting, but I think there are better Ghost Stories out there. Turn of the Screw comes to mind. Oct 29, PM. Read this recently and it is really good. The film scared the pants of me but the book is even scarier. Turn of the Screw gives me the willies. Nov 19, PM. I didn't even read the book yet.

I keep forgetting, but the trailer is wonderful. Nov 20, AM. Turn of the screw- one adaptation was the creepiest thing I ever saw. I was in the house on my own. I checked under the bed, behind he door everywhere before I went to sleep:.

Nov 23, PM. I have finally finished this blasted book and have time to at least answer the questions. I think the author creates suspense through the fact that the narrator, Arthur Kipps, is so fricken calm while he is telling the story, even at the very end when he telling the scariest, tragic part he is still calm, accepts the price that had to be paid and now feels that having told his tale he can finally move on.

That ending was chilling. Not only did I trust Arthur, but his level-headedness makes the ending all that more tragic and scary She is creeptastic. It's so effective because I, like Arthur, would get used to her or the story or the setting and then something else would be added to make me even more frightened. I'm not sure that I like the treatment of women in this novel Stella seems to be blindly devoted, so does his 2nd wife and, of course, Mrs. Drablow seems to have had the right intention I guess, but not really as she knew how the woman felt, but went against her wishes anyway.

Let's look at it through the Bechtel Test 1. Does it have at least 2 women in it? Yes, Stella, new wife, the woman in black, Mrs. Drablow 2. Do they talk to each other? About something besides a man? So, the answer is also no. Which means, in terms of how this book portrays women it gets an F.

The idea of having a tradition where one tells ghost stories on Christmas Eve is a bit disturbing. The historical setting adds to the horror because we are playing with three very distinctive time periods Georgian, Victorian and Edwardian Although this story really does remind me of The Amityville Horror , in the sense that the house is also a character.

I love that this novel is actually a ghost story and not one of those scary stories that relies on loads of violence or gruesomeness to create suspense and terrify the reader. I think it's better than most of the stuff that we have out nowadays I love that after a certain point this book really cannot be put down and it is just frightening. Nov 24, AM. The main problem with adapting this book into a movie is that so much of it happens internally, and it just didn't translate. It would have had to be a very narration-heavy movie and they didn't go that route not that I'm saying that would have worked, it probably wouldn't have.

The house that had so much character in the book also looses a lot of its force in the movie because it wasn't treated as a character, just as a piece of scenery. The movie was pretty lacklustre in my opinion, the book is definitely much better. Add a reference: Book Author. Search for a book to add a reference. We take abuse seriously in our discussion boards. Only flag comments that clearly need our attention.

As a general rule we do not censor any content on the site. The only content we will consider removing is spam, slanderous attacks on other members, or extremely offensive content eg. We will not remove any content for bad language alone, or being critical of a particular book. Group Home Bookshelf Discussions. Events Photos Videos. Invite People Members Polls.

Girl, Woman, Other Book Review

The Woman in Black is a horror novel by Susan Hill , written in the style of a traditional Gothic novel. The plot concerns a mysterious spectre that haunts a small English town. A television film based on the story, also called The Woman in Black , was produced in , with a screenplay by Nigel Kneale. In , a theatrical film adaptation of the same name was released, starring Daniel Radcliffe. The book has also been adapted into a stage play by Stephen Mallatratt.

Her husband, Frank, eats a steak for dinner every night, watches a few minutes of TV, and then turns in. Patty yearns for a baby, but Frank is always too tired for that kind of thing.

T his is a ghost story, so we start with the storyteller. Literary critics rarely use this last term, preferring to talk of the "narrator". But when it comes to hauntings this traditional description is fitting. Arthur Kipps is giving us a tale that he is condemned by his own memories to tell. When the novella opens, he is a man in late middle age, surrounded by adult stepchildren at Christmas.

2ser Breakfast

W hen I am emailed by pupils studying The Woman in Black for GCSE and A-level, many refer to it as "gothic", and indeed it forms part of a university course in gothic literature. But although the book has something in common with the pure gothic fiction of the 18th and 19th centuries, it is really only a distant cousin of the genre. It is a ghost story — not a horror story, not a thriller — and not a gothic novel; although the terms are often used very loosely, they are not by any means the same thing. I set out to write a ghost story in the classic 19th-century tradition, a full-length one. The list of ingredients included atmosphere, a ghost, a haunted house and other places, and weather. A footnote to "ghost" was a of a human being; and b with a purpose. There are dozens of little books of "true" ghost stories, usually sorted by geographical location, but almost without exception the ghosts have no purpose and so the stories are ultimately unsatisfying.

40 Great Book Club Discussion Questions For Any Book

Uh-oh, it looks like your Internet Explorer is out of date. For a better shopping experience, please upgrade now. Javascript is not enabled in your browser. Enabling JavaScript in your browser will allow you to experience all the features of our site.

Methinks feminism has a way to go yet. Like many ex-pats who left Australian in the s, St John paints Australia as a cultural desert.

Log In. Like every other horror story or movie protagonist ever, Arthur Kipps just won't leave the site of the haunting. Why do you think he decides to stay on? Why does Jennet think it's okay to exact revenge on other people's children?

The Woman in Black by Susan Hill

Have you ever wondered about how life would have been " if "? Have you ever wondered about what would have happened " if " you had done something different? Did you think that what was in your imagination never matched your reality? Have you known children that seemed to have been in tune with you before you could speak?

Most of these are non-specific, designed to work for any book, although, of course, some will work better than others for particular books. Just pick and choose the discussion questions that work best for you and your book group, and get the conversation going! Bring the printable questions along for help. If too short, what would you add? What other title might you choose?

The Woman in Black

Madeleine St. John was born in Sydney in In she moved to the United States and attended Stanford, and later moved to England to attend Cambridge University. In , she published her debut novel in Australia, The Women in Black. John was the first Australian woman to receive this honor. John died in The Women in Black : A Novel. Madeleine St John.

Nov 13, - The Women in Black is set in s Sydney, but it couldn't possibly No wonder Clive James and Barry Humphries like this book Source: Review copy sent to me by Text, but I also had my own copy, I do know what you mean if someone asked me a question I'd have to go back to the book too.

A great year for the Booker Prize. Girl, Woman, Other Book Review. As Evaristo says herself in this interview, who better to share the Booker with than Atwood. Anyway, Evaristo did not disappoint. Far from it.

The Women in Black

This topic is about The Woman in Black. Oct 24, AM. Hello All, I'm still reading the book, but I found these discussion questions and liked the first two didn't read the last ones, just in case they give the ending away!

Discussion Questions for 'The woman in black' by Susan Hill 1. The novel opens with a detailed description of happy family life and builds to a ghastly climax. How does the author create the continual suspense to bring things to their terrifying conclusion?

- В чем разница.

ТРАНСТЕКСТ заклинило. Фонтейн повернулся к окну. - Господи Исусе. Раздался телефонный звонок.

Один из них, к ее удивлению, был адресом анонимного провайдера. Сьюзан открыла одно из старых входящих сообщений, и у нее тотчас же перехватило дыхание. ТО: NDAKOTAARA. ANON. ORG FROM: ETDOSH1SHA. EDU И далее текст сообщения: ГРОМАДНЫЙ ПРОГРЕСС. ЦИФРОВАЯ КРЕПОСТЬ ПОЧТИ ГОТОВА.

Да, - сказал Беккер.  - Мы кое-что упустили. ГЛАВА 13 Токуген Нуматака стоял у окна своего роскошного кабинета на верхнем этаже небоскреба и разглядывал завораживающие очертания Токио на фоне ярко-синего неба.

Comments: 2
  1. Nalrajas

    What remarkable phrase

  2. Takree

    In my opinion you are not right. I suggest it to discuss. Write to me in PM, we will communicate.

Thanks! Your comment will appear after verification.
Add a comment

© 2020 Online - Advisor on specific issues.